History
The “Sinners” Jesus Ate With
Who were the “sinners” Jesus ate with? Explore the welcome, forgiveness, and call to repentance found in the Gospels.
The “sinners” Jesus ate with were people known for lives considered contrary to God’s will, including tax collectors. The word also expressed a judgment about who deserved trust and companionship. Jesus drew near to these people to offer forgiveness and call them to repentance, that is, to turn away from sin and return to God.
His meals therefore raised questions: welcoming someone into one’s home or accepting their hospitality made that welcome visible. The Gospels show Jesus giving attention both to people with bad reputations and to respected religious people. The table became a place of encounter, teaching, and invitation to a transformed life.
Who was called a “sinner”?
In these accounts, “sinners” is not the name of an organization with its own leaders and rules. It is a label applied to people whose conduct was disapproved of. We should not confuse this usage with the Christian affirmation that everyone needs God’s forgiveness: in the discussion about meals, the term distinguished certain people from those seen as respectable.
Tax collectors frequently appear alongside them. Luke relates that Levi was working at a tax booth when Jesus called him, and later held a banquet in his home (Luke 5:27-32). He also presents Zacchaeus as a wealthy chief tax collector who welcomed Jesus despite complaints from those who considered him a sinner (Luke 19:1-10).
These examples prevent an oversimplification: the label did not simply mean poverty or lack of education. Scholars often associate tax collectors with a reputation for dishonesty and those called sinners with disregard for the Law. This is a reconstruction, and the precise definition of the term is debated; it does not allow us to conclude that everyone had the same story or committed the same sins.
Why did eating with them draw criticism?
Luke 15:1-2 presents the conflict directly: tax collectors and sinners gathered to hear Jesus, while Pharisees, members of a Jewish movement devoted to observing the Law, and teachers of the law criticized his company. The complaint recorded in the NIV is: “This man welcomes sinners and eats with them.” What troubled them was a closeness everyone could see.
In the culture of the time, sharing a meal demonstrated relationship and belonging. The choice of guests therefore communicated something about who was accepted as company. Scholars debate, however, how much ritual purity, the religious conditions for participating in certain practices, mattered in these conflicts. The researcher Cecilia Wassen, for example, questions the idea that these meals in themselves prove a violation of purity rules.
The biblical text explains Jesus’ response through parables, stories that teach through familiar situations. The lost sheep and the lost coin are sought and joyfully found, in a comparison with the joy over a sinner who repents (Luke 15:3-10). In the story of the two sons, the celebration of the younger son’s return and the older son’s resistance return to the question of welcome (Luke 15:11-32).
The woman in Simon’s house
Luke 7:36-50 shows Jesus dining in the house of Simon, a Pharisee. A woman known in the town as a sinner arrives with perfume, weeps at Jesus’ feet, wets his feet with her tears, wipes them with her hair, and pours out the perfume. Luke gives neither her name nor her occupation; the account therefore does not justify claiming that she was a prostitute or Mary Magdalene.
Simon inwardly questions whether Jesus knows who is touching him. Jesus responds with the story of two debtors forgiven different debts and asks which will love the person who forgave them more. He then compares the woman’s actions with his host’s welcome, drawing Simon’s attention to the love she was showing.
Jesus acknowledges the woman’s many sins and announces her forgiveness. The story of the debts helps us understand her actions as a response to forgiveness, and Jesus says that her faith has saved her, sending her away in peace. Simon, in turn, is invited to reconsider his judgment.
“I have not come to call the righteous”: welcome and repentance
At Levi’s banquet, Jesus responds to criticism by comparing his mission to the work of a doctor who treats the sick. The comparison explains why he draws near to those who need help (Luke 5:27-32). The following verse makes the purpose of this encounter clear:
“I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance.”
Luke 5:32, NIV
This response does not certify the innocence of those who consider themselves righteous. Its focus is Jesus’ mission: the need for forgiveness explains his closeness to sinners. Repentance involves acknowledging wrongdoing and changing direction; a good reputation alone cannot replace this response to God.
The visit to Zacchaeus provides a concrete example. As he welcomes Jesus, he speaks of sharing his possessions with the poor and making restitution to anyone he has cheated; Jesus announces salvation for that house (Luke 19:1-10). Welcome and responsibility appear together, showing that an encounter with Jesus also affects the use of money and the treatment of others.
The lesson for today and the path to the nations
The first application is to examine whom we avoid before even hearing their story. A Christian community can welcome people with difficult pasts, speak respectfully, and proclaim forgiveness while teaching a life of obedience to Jesus. This includes taking those who have suffered injustice seriously and encouraging restitution for harm wherever possible.
We also need to read these conflicts without turning Jews or Pharisees into caricatures. Jesus was Jewish (John 4:9), and the meal with Simon itself shows that he maintained contact with people from that movement. The account challenges attitudes of judgment and self-sufficiency that can appear in any community, including our own, and does not justify hostility toward a people.
Jesus reached people from different groups, and his command to make disciples, people learning to follow him, includes all nations (Matthew 28:18-20). This guides our prayer for unreached peoples, those with little access to Jesus’ message: we ask for opportunities to listen, bear witness, and believe.
We can begin by welcoming people from other backgrounds near us, learning their names, and respectfully sharing a meal. Jesus’ table teaches us to be present with people and proclaim the possibility of a new life with God. See also the other groups in the time of Jesus.
History Who were the tax collectors and why were they hated
History Who were the Sadducees?
History Who were the Samaritans and why did Jews and Samaritans not get along